In
Search of Balance
Sizing up the American Dream
By Jenn Lackey
It's
an age-old question: What does the American Dream mean these
days? Does it mean a house with 2.5 kids and a pet? Does
it mean the possession of material wealth or something less
concrete and nebulous such as the freedom to choose your
own path? Today many Americans struggle under a mountain
of debt while longing for more free time. It's questionable
whether or not America can support enough opportunity for
all its citizens. Is there still opportunity for hard work
and discipline to pay off?
The term American Dream comes from Pulitzer prizewinner
historian James Truslow Adams. In 1931, during the Great
Depression, Adams coined the phrase in a written exposition
called Epic of America. He wanted to publish his arguments
into a book called The American Dream. He rejected the notion
that the American dream was based on possession and wealth,
"It is not a dream of motor cars and high wages merely,
but a dream of a social order in which each man and each
woman shall be able to attain to the fullest stature of
which they are innately capable, and be recognized by others
for what they are, regardless of the fortuitous circumstances
of birth or position," wrote Adams. Ironically, his American
dream was never published. His publisher didn't think anyone
would pay to read about such a fleeting notion.
More than 70 years later many folks associate the American
dream more with wealth than Adams original vision of each
man and woman attaining his or her own innate stature. A
San Francisco based mechanical design engineer and 98' Stanford
University graduate, Ben Gallant, took a whole class on
the subject. "Right now it seems that the prevailing ideal
is ownership of a nice house, a SUV, a sweet surround sound
home theater, and access to low prices at Wall Mart. This
idea gets fueled by the capitalism slash advertising machine
so that the underlying dream of opportunity and freedom
gets confused with the image of material wealth."
Mary Wagner, a retired 82-year-old Wausau Insurance employee
living in Wisconsin is a testimony that the American Dream
has evolved to mean more about material possessions since
the 1930s. "I was raised during the depression when people
didn't have anything. People who were young in that era
are very conservative. We hang on to everything because
we remember what those times were like and we saved and
saved. We raised the Baby Boomers and I don't think they're
saving enough for retirement. Why is bankruptcy such a big
issue?"
One could argue mass consumerism and 'keeping up with the
Joneses' was established in the 1940s and 1950s after the
U.S. economy recovered from the Depression. The G.I. Bill
of 1944 afforded millions of Americans the ability to obtain
a college education, buy their first home and comfortably
reproduce. Roughly 77 million Americans were born between
1946 and 1964. During the 1970s and 1980s suddenly a huge
portion of the U.S. population was between the ages of 20
- 40, traditionally the portion of society with the most
amount of disposable income. Young, urban professionals,
known as Yuppies, gave way to mass consumerism.
Today more Americans are declaring bankruptcy than are graduating
from college, according to the Takoma Park, Md. nonprofit
Center for a New American Dream http://www.newdream.org.
Household debt, personal bankruptcies and home foreclosures
hit an all time high in 2002. Also, household debt in the
U.S. exceeded America's annual disposable income for the
first time totaling $8 trillion, according to a recent Atlantic
Monthly article.
Throughout the recent recession Americans continued to spend.
Thanks to the lowest interest rates since the 1960s more
young people have become homeowners and those with equity
became new SUV owners. Thank you Alan Greenspan. The point
is consumerism keeps America's economy healthy, and that's
good for the government. The American Dream is a great public
relations slogan.
However, the surge of personal debt is causing many Americans
to work longer hours and feel greater pressure. At the dawn
of the 21st century many Americans are looking for a healthier
balance between work and time spent with family and friends.
The Center for a New American Dream also found "the average
employed American now works more than 47 hours a week in
the struggle to keep up with mounting bills, causing tremendous
stress." Another recent study conducted by the Center found
that "52% employees would take a day off per week over a
day's pay. About one-fifth of workers say they would go
a step further, accepting an overall pay cut to have more
free time and feel less pressure and stress." Focused on
sustainable consumerism their battle cry is "More fun! Less
Stuff!" A group of academics, government officials, environmentalists,
organizers, religious leaders, consumer activists, and economists
launched the organization in 1997.
Richard Florida Heinz professor of economic development
at Carnegie Mellon University echoes The Center's vision.
In recent Washington Monthly article he argues, the new
American Dream is no longer about money. "The new American
Dream is to maintain a reasonable living standard while
doing work that we enjoy doing," writes Florida, "In fact,
many people are willing to trade income for work they enjoy.
I've interviewed countless professionals who left secure
jobs for riskier new ventures, often at lower pay, not for
a shot at a stock-option bonanza but for a chance to do
work that excites them."
Sarah Thompson, a 33-year-old writer and stay at home mom
supports Florida's view. "My American Dream is of a country
where people are given the opportunity and are encouraged
to do work that is satisfying, creates, adds positively
to the universe and is not the center of one's life."
It seems as though we're slowing evolving back to Adams
original definition of the American Dream. "The American
Dream to me means an economic capacity and sufficient opportunity
to allow hard work and discipline to manifest whatever goal
that I have set my eyes on at the time. It's the idea that
I can be anything or do anything that I set out to do,"
says Sarah, Sarah Ainsworth, a 28-year-old, Operations Manager
working at an Oakland, CA based investment advisory firm.
The bottom line is that the American Dream isn't found in
your wallet. It's about hope and faith in the ability to
work toward a personal goal. Hard work and discipline don't
always pay off for Middle Americans, but "Is it correct
to judge the American Dream on whether or not we live in
a fair country?" Asks Jesse Simons, a 31-year-old Director
of Development for a national environmental organization,
"The point is not the reality but the myth of the 'dream'.
Even those truly affected by cynicism have to admit that
it's still possible to come from nothing and become successful
in this country. And that hope is all a lot of people ever
have."
|